Skip to main content

Start here

Free Car Calculators

100% free · No sign-up · Private Free car calculators. Know the real cost before you buy. Simple, accurate tools for car loans, affordability, leasing, fuel, depreciation and total cost of ownership. Everything runs in your browser and updates as you type. All calculators Car Loan Calculator Monthly payment, total interest and a year-by-year payoff schedule. How Much Car Can I Afford? Find a realistic car budget from your income using the 20/4/10 rule. Lease vs Buy Calculator Compare the real cost of leasing and financing the same car. Fuel Cost Calculator Gas cost for any trip in miles/MPG or km/L per 100 km. Car Depreciation Calculator See how much value your car loses each year. True Cost of Car Ownership Everything a car really costs: depreciation, fuel, insurance and more. Why use CarCostWise? Instant results Every calculator updates as you type. No buttons, no waiting, no pop-ups. Private by design Your numbers never leave your device. We don't store what you ent...

New vs Used Car: Which Is Cheaper Over 5 Years?

New vs Used Car

A new car comes with a warranty, the latest features and that new-car smell. A used car comes with a lower price. But which one actually costs less once you add everything up? The answer depends mostly on one thing: depreciation.

The biggest difference: depreciation

New cars lose value fastest in their first few years. When you buy a 2 to 3 year old car, the first owner has already absorbed that steep drop. You still pay depreciation, but less of it each year.

Compare a new and a used car side by sideFree, instant and private: everything runs in your browser.
Open the True Cost of Ownership Calculator →

A simple comparison

Imagine the same model, bought new for $35,000 or at 3 years old for $22,000, and kept for five years. Using typical depreciation rates (20% in the first year, 15% per year after), here's roughly what each loses:

New ($35,000)3-year-old ($22,000)
Value after 5 yearsabout $14,600about $9,800
Depreciation over 5 yearsabout $20,400about $12,200

In this example, the used car saves about $8,000 in depreciation alone. It usually saves on sales tax, loan interest and sometimes insurance too, because all of those depend on the price.

Where a new car can win back ground

  • Repairs. A new car is under full warranty; a used car may need tires, brakes or bigger repairs sooner.
  • Financing. New cars often get promotional rates that used cars don't.
  • Fuel efficiency and safety. Newer models may use less fuel and have better safety features.
  • Known history. You're the first owner, so there's no hidden accident or maintenance history.

How to buy a used car safely

  1. Check the vehicle history report for accidents, title problems and odometer issues.
  2. Get a pre-purchase inspection from an independent mechanic.
  3. Look at certified pre-owned (CPO) programs if you want an extended warranty.
  4. Compare prices across several listings for the same model, year and mileage.

Which should you choose?

For most budgets, a 2 to 4 year old car with a good reliability record is the sweet spot: much of the depreciation is gone, but the car still has many good years left. A new car makes more sense if you get a strong financing deal, plan to keep it 10 years or more, or want specific features and peace of mind.

Run your own comparison

Use our True Cost of Ownership Calculator twice: once for the new car and once for the used one, with your own price, insurance and fuel numbers. The difference in total cost is your answer. The Car Depreciation Calculator helps you estimate each car's future value.

Compare a new and a used car side by sideFree, instant and private: everything runs in your browser.
Open the True Cost of Ownership Calculator →

Comments

Popular Posts